| Costs | Gym Monster 2S | OMNI X1 Pro | Tonal 2 | S1 Pro |
|---|
| Package compared | 2S · Works Plus | Beginner bundle · incline bench included | Tonal 2 + Essentials + base install | S1 Pro complete set + B3S bench |
|---|
| Upfront CostHardware / selected bundle | $4,299 | $2,955 | $4,790 | $4,499 |
|---|
| Setup / InstallationAdditional required setup | $0 additional modeled | $0 additional modeled | From $295 installation | $0 additional modeled |
|---|
| Monthly CostBilling basis is shown | $0 required for core access | $0 required for core access | $59.95/mo · selected full service | $0 required for core access |
|---|
| Subscription & cancellationRequired versus optional | Core training $0; optional Wellness+ excluded | No mandatory subscription | 59.95/mo; first 12mo required; full access modeled throughout | All training content included; $0 subscription |
|---|
| 1-Year Total Cost | $4,299Official listed price | $2,955Official US bundle price | From $5,804.40Minimum · ZIP surcharge possible | $4,499Live US variant price |
|---|
| 3-Year Total Cost | $4,299Official listed price | $2,955Official US bundle price | From $7,243.20Minimum · ZIP surcharge possible | $4,499Live US variant price |
|---|
| 5-Year Total Cost | $4,299Official listed price | $2,955Official US bundle price | From $8,682Minimum · ZIP surcharge possible | $4,499Live US variant price |
|---|
| Availability / price basis | Sold out / legacy listing | US stock listed | Installation varies by ZIP | Bench may ship separately |
|---|
| Training | Gym Monster 2S | OMNI X1 Pro | Tonal 2 | S1 Pro |
|---|
| Resistance RangeTotal and per cable | 260 lb total · 130 per cable | 264–265 lb total · 132 per cable | 250 lb total · 125 per cable | 220 lb total · 110 per arm |
|---|
| Cables / positioning | 2 independent cables | 2 cables · adjustable arms | 2 cables · adjustable arms | 2 cables · 185 arm angles |
|---|
| Eccentric Mode | ✓ Yes · eccentric mode | ✓ Yes · adjustable eccentric overload | ✓ Yes · paid membership | ✓ Yes · eccentric mode |
|---|
| Spotter ModeLoad release is not always automatic | Safety Start + adaptive protection | Speed-based unload, grip release, imbalance protection | ✓ Yes · Spotter / Burnout with membership | Smart Assist offload + support arms |
|---|
| Training Modes | Standard / eccentric / chain / constant modes | Standard / eccentric / spring / isokinetic / pull-up assist | Eccentric / chains / Smart Flex / Spotter | Constant / concentric / eccentric / elastic / row / HIIT |
|---|
| Form Feedback | Software coaching; not a built-in skeletal camera | App-guided plans; no K1-style camera claim | Form coaching; feature-dependent | 42-point camera + 6D assessment |
|---|
| Software | Gym Monster 2S | OMNI X1 Pro | Tonal 2 | S1 Pro |
|---|
| App QualityWorkflow + attributed experience | Touchscreen programs + custom workouts; Toby reports firmware regressions | 21.5in display; customizable sessions | Polished guided / custom programming; original-Tonal owner context | Custom workouts / supersets; 9 profiles |
|---|
| Data Tracking | Reps, load, volume, workout history | Load, reps and app workout progress | Load, reps, volume and progression with membership | Movement recognition, reps and progress |
|---|
| Offline / without membership | Free training supported; connected features need internet | Offline course availability not published | Basic lifting after cancellation; dynamic modes / logs removed | Free Workout works; AI / courses need internet |
|---|
| Ownership | Gym Monster 2S | OMNI X1 Pro | Tonal 2 | S1 Pro |
|---|
| WarrantySelected region / components | 2yr main unit; 1yr accessories | 2yr complete machine | 2yr trainer parts/labor/shipping; 1yr smart accessories | 2yr main unit; 1yr accessories |
|---|
| Customer SupportChannels; owner experience labeled | Email + phone; owner firmware complaints documented | Manufacturer email; 24/7 service advertised | Phone / email / installation service; owner complaints separately | Direct email / phone; customer pays preference-return freight |
|---|
| Space RequiredDevice size ≠ exercise clearance | Open 48 × 27.2 × 72.8 in; folded 14.6 × 27.2 × 72.8 in | Open 55.9 × 36.8 × 74.8 in; stored 71.9 × 5.7 × 36.8 in | 8 × 8ft training area; unit 21.5 × 50.9 × 5.25 in | Exercise clearance 63 × 70.9 × 86.6 in; folded 28.1 × 16.7 × 72.8 in |
|---|
| Setup | Freestanding · no drilling · mains power | Freestanding · mains · destination-specific voltage | Professional wall installation | Fully assembled · plug in · no wall work |
|---|
| Portability | Folding base; room-to-room, not travel | 180 lb machine; folding mechanism | Fixed installation; moving requires service | 243 lb machine; folding base |
|---|
| Evidence / experience | Toby owns 2S | Episode discussion | Owns the original Tonal and chose not to get this device | Requested addition · published specs |
|---|